Second Opinions

Making Informed Decisions About Your Health

When it comes to your health, every decision matters. If you’ve been told you may need orthopedic surgery, it’s natural to have questions: Is surgery the only option? What are the risks? Should I get a second opinion?

Every year, thousands of people are advised that they may need surgery for an orthopedic condition. It’s completely normal to want more information, explore alternatives, or confirm that you’re choosing the right path forward. Getting a second opinion can help you better understand your diagnosis, your treatment options, and what different experts recommend.

A common misconception is that your current doctor will be upset if you seek another opinion. In reality, it’s standard practice—and something most physicians encourage, especially before surgery. A second opinion can give you clarity, peace of mind, and confidence that you’re making the best possible decision for your health and lifestyle.

Why Get a Second Opinion?

Choosing a course of treatment is a big decision, so it’s important to make sure that you have all the information you need. Second opinions can help:

• Confirm your diagnosis and feel confident you understand your condition fully
• Ensure you’re considering all treatment options, including nonsurgical alternatives
• Get input from another highly qualified orthopedic specialist
• Better understand the potential benefits, risks, and recovery process
• Make an informed choice that fits your goals, activity level, and comfort

Second Opinions at Columbia Orthopedics

The orthopedic specialists at Columbia University Irving Medical Center/NewYork-Presbyterian Hospital are leaders in their field—nationally recognized for their expertise in diagnosing and treating complex musculoskeletal conditions. Our team is at the forefront of using advanced imaging, minimally invasive procedures, and state-of-the-art surgical techniques to achieve the best outcomes possible.

Beyond clinical excellence, our physicians are also researchers and educators, driving innovation in orthopedic care. They continue to advance the science of bone, joint, and muscle health through pioneering research and outcome-based studies—ensuring that every patient benefits from the latest evidence-based treatments.

When you come to Columbia for a second opinion, you gain access to a multidisciplinary team of experts who collaborate to provide a clear diagnosis, thoughtful guidance, and a personalized plan tailored to your individual needs.

How Does It Work?

You’ll begin by scheduling a consultation—either in person or through a virtual visit—with one of our orthopedic specialists. Before your appointment, we’ll review your medical history, test results, imaging, and any prior treatment plans.

During your visit, your physician will:

• Discuss your symptoms and goals
• Review your diagnosis and any imaging or lab results
• Explain all available treatment options (both nonsurgical and surgical)
• Provide a clear, expert recommendation for next steps

Our team will collaborate internally at Columbia University Irving Medical Center/NewYork-Presbyterian Hospital to ensure that your second opinion reflects the best, most current medical thinking and technology available.

What Are the Next Steps?

Scheduling a second opinion is simple.

You can choose:

• Virtual Visit via Telehealth: Our team can review your case remotely and provide a detailed evaluation.
• In-Person Consultation: Visit one of our convenient Columbia Orthopedics locations across the New York area.

To schedule your second opinion appointment, call 212-305-4565 or contact our team online.